Beyond the Noise: Discovering Uncommon Profits Through Fundamental Insight
In the complex world of common stock investing, where daily fluctuations scream for attention and the financial community often seems guided by noise, how does an investor seek truly uncommon profits? The secret lies not in tracking ephemeral trends but in adopting a profound, disciplined investment philosophy rooted in qualitative business analysis. This approach rejects conventional wisdom in favor of deep, foundational understanding, centering around two primary “jewels” of insight: The Scuttlebutt Method and The Fifteen Points for identifying superior enterprises.
This methodology advocates for finding a very few great companies that you can truly understand and holding them for a long, long time. It is a system designed for conservative investing, defined as maintaining purchasing power while minimizing risk.
Part I: The Quest for Deep Knowledge: Embracing the Scuttlebutt Method
Many investors rely on the local rumor mill or general Wall Street noise, much of which is simply aimed at selling product. The Scuttlebutt method offers a radical alternative: finding out from real, “Main Street” sources whether a firm is strong or weak.
Scuttlebutt involves obtaining hard-to-fake features of a company by seeking information from those who interact directly with it: competitors, customers, and suppliers. These external sources possess a vested interest in the target company and often speak freely about their competitors if they feel there is no danger of being quoted. By asking individuals in an industry about rival companies, one gains profound insights.
The Art and Craft of Scuttlebutt
The application of the fifteen points—the checklist for what to buy—is a repeatable, real-world experience linked directly to Scuttlebutt. While the initial application of the method is a craft (asking questions to get answers), mastery requires artistry. The art of Scuttlebutt involves transforming initial answers into better, and deeper, follow-up questions.
A successful investor uses Scuttlebutt to obtain a complete picture of a company. For instance, assessing the relative efficiency of a sales organization is easiest through Scuttlebutt, as competitors and customers are often unhesitant to express their views on this subject.
The successful pursuit of knowledge also demands discipline and preparation. If an investor plans to visit a company’s management, acquiring substantial background knowledge first is crucial. Management typically dedicates valuable time to visitors; their willingness to provide specific, vital information depends heavily on their estimate of the visitor’s preparedness. Without adequate advance work, finding the right answers relies too heavily on luck.
Part II: The Blueprint for Excellence: The Fifteen Points
The Fifteen Points provide a framework for determining what attributes a company must possess to offer the greatest likelihood of achieving major gains for shareholders. These points categorize the required characteristics into operational (functional) factors, people factors, and unique business characteristics.
Dimension 1: Functional Factors (Operational Excellence)
The first dimension of a conservative investment focuses on outstanding managerial competence in the basic areas of production, marketing, research, and financial controls.
1. R&D and Product Development: The Lifeblood of Growth
The first point for consideration is that a company must possess products or services with sufficient market potential to allow a substantial sales increase for several years. More critically, a truly outstanding company is not content with a single spurt of growth but rather seeks to develop a continuous flow of new, profitable products or product lines.
Growth should be judged not on an annual basis, which can be heavily influenced by business cycles or commercial research intricacies, but over units of several years. This constant innovation means the investor usually finds the best results in companies where research is dedicated to products somewhat different from competitors. The success of modern research depends less on a single genius and more on a highly trained, coordinated team of specialists (chemists, physicists, etc.).
2. Marketing and Sales Organization: Translating Innovation into Revenue
A company must have an above-average sales organization. Selling ability is just as crucial as having worthwhile new products. A strong marketer must be constantly alert to the changing desires of its customers and react promptly.
However, recognizing changes isn’t enough. In the competitive world, potential customers must be made aware of the product’s advantages. This awareness must be created by explaining the product’s benefits in the customer’s terms, sometimes even when the customer doesn’t clearly recognize why those advantages appeal to them. The overall success of production and research hinges upon efficient liaison between those functions and a strong marketing arm.
3. Financial Controls and Profit Margins
Outstanding success over a long period demands tight cost controls. The truly astute company maintains comprehensive cost analysis and accounting controls, allowing management to break down overall costs accurately to show the cost of each small step in its operation. This enables management to judge what needs attention and whether problems are being properly solved.
Companies that yield the biggest investment gains usually maintain relatively broad profit margins—often the best in their respective industries. High profit margins are attractive to competitors, likened to an open jar of honey drawing a swarm of hungry insects. To protect profitability indefinitely, a company must possess inherent characteristics, such as economies of scale or a unique market position. A strong financial team provides advantages such as cost reduction, improved profit mix, and capital conservation through tight control of working capital investments.
Dimension 2: The People Factor (Management Quality and Culture)
The second dimension is the quality of the people controlling the company’s activities and the policies they establish. This is encapsulated in questions about management competence and employee relations.
4. Management Depth and Integrity
A cornerstone of a worthwhile investment is management integrity and a highly developed sense of trusteeship toward stockholders. Beyond mere honesty, this involves management’s dedication to building the long-term fortune of the firm. Management must have a clear, concrete, open-ended plan to maintain and improve profitability.
A growth-oriented chief executive must be willing to delegate substantial authority to a competent team, ensuring depth in management. Successful firms must be led by an entrepreneurial personality combining drive, original ideas, and the skills needed to build the firm’s fortunes.
5. Employee Relations and Loyalty
A genuine, continuous effort to ensure employees at every level feel the company is a good place to work is essential. Management should foster loyalty and productivity through good communication, allowing people to express grievances without fear, and ensuring suggestions are welcomed and evaluated, even if they criticize current practices. Grievances should be addressed quickly, as long-smoldering grievances are usually the most costly.
6. The Forward-Looking Question
A critical question management must constantly address is: “What are you doing that your competitors aren’t doing yet?”. The emphasis here is on the word yet. A firm that consistently asks this question avoids complacency, prevents being caught behind, and ensures a constant striving for a better future, enabling it to drive the market and dominate for a long time. This attitude is a key ingredient for true long-range growth.
Dimension 3: Business Characteristics (Inherent Advantages)
The third dimension deals with inherent business characteristics that allow for above-average profitability indefinitely.
7. Competitive Advantage and Market Position
A company needs inherent qualities that make it difficult for newcomers to successfully share in its growth. These qualities enable well-managed companies to maintain above-average profit margins long-term. This is the central question of this dimension: “What particular company do that others would not be able to do?”.
Industry leadership is not solely achieved through technology; it can also come from developing a consumer “franchise” or achieving service excellence. For example, scattering canning plants strategically can provide cost advantages through reduced hauling for both growers and customers.
8. Dividend Policy and Capital Reinvestment
The decision to pay dividends is often misunderstood. Retaining earnings for building new plants and launching new products has often provided spectacular advantage to investors. Managements that win approval usually hold that a dividend should be raised cautiously, only when it can be maintained, and lowered only in the gravest emergencies. Shifting dividend policies erratically can be detrimental to the company’s reputation, similar to a restaurant that changes its menu wildly without warning. For growth companies, the need for capital stability and funding growth sometimes mandates that they pay no dividends at all.
Part III: The Disciplines of Uncommon Investing
Identifying the right company is only half the battle; the second half involves the mental discipline necessary to secure the gains.
Patience and the Three-Year Rule
The true growth investor is rewarded by selecting successful growth stocks and holding them. This requires a significant degree of patience and self-discipline. The author established a “three-year rule” for his clients: allowing a three-year period for a purchase to produce worthwhile results, after which the client should fire him if goals are unmet. This rule acknowledges that temporary periods of poor market action or client criticism must be endured if the underlying conviction in the company is sound.
Outstanding companies fundamentally differ from those whose potential is used up once their stock price rises. If a company maintains superior qualities, selling simply because the price has advanced substantially is usually a mistake. Instead, the stock should be held for a long time.
When to Buy: Thinking Contrary
The investor must determine when to buy a stock that meets the Fifteen Points criteria. When the market has a severe decline, investors who stagger their purchases over several years will still have purchasing power available to take advantage of the decline.
A key opportunity arises when a company is temporarily out of favor due to the market’s prevailing sentiment, despite the strength of the company’s real-world affairs. This is the essence of being successful: having the ability to “zig when the crowd zags,” provided one has strong indications that their “zigging” is correct. Significant profits are available to those who successfully move contrary to the general financial community. When management is successfully driving the product market and forcing competitors to follow, investors should recognize this as a critical opportunity.
Avoiding Investment Pitfalls
Several common mistakes hinder investors from achieving uncommon returns:
- Don’t Buy Promotional Companies: It is extremely difficult to obtain the desired “batting average” for selecting outstanding companies if one invests in firms that lack at least two or three years of commercial operation and one year of operating profit. When a company is in the promotional stage, the investor can only review a blueprint and guess at the problems and strong points.
- Don’t Over-Diversify: Many average investors hold twenty-five or more different stocks, which is often appalling and unnecessary. Adequate diversification can often be achieved with as few as five or six stocks, provided they are in completely different industries with different manufacturing problems and competition. Focusing resources on a smaller number of stocks allows the investor to know their holdings deeply, which is the cornerstone of success.
- Don’t Judge Quality by Price: Investors should focus on the quality and growth prospects of the underlying business, not just the cheapness of the stock price. It is costly to overlook the unexpectedly large number of truly outstanding opportunities in firms that the financial community has temporarily misappraised.
Conclusion: The Timeless Advantage
The philosophy articulated in these writings focuses on understanding the anatomy of a conservative investment—one with above-average ability in production, marketing, research, and financial controls—backed by superb people and inherent business advantages. The core methodology of diligent, boots-on-the-ground investigation—Scuttlebutt—coupled with the demanding benchmark of the Fifteen Points, remains a worthwhile approach for any serious investor seeking truly uncommon profits.
Ultimately, obtaining profound investment results is a function of combining hard work, ingenuity, and integrity. The deeper you read and understand these principles, the more insight you will gain throughout your investing life.
(Disclaimer: The original texts, Common Stocks and Uncommon Profits and Other Writings, contain detailed explanations of the Fifteen Points and other principles, only excerpts of which have been used to construct this blog post. For a full understanding of these powerful concepts, the source material should be consulted).
Best Books to Read and Listen 